FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Books, dissertations, abstract

Pages:   || 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |   ...   | 42 |

«A thesis submitted to the University of East Anglia for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy By Shane Brown School of Film, Television and Media ©This ...»

-- [ Page 1 ] --


A Comparative Analysis of Representations of Male Queerness and Male-Male

Intimacy in the Films of Europe and America, 1912-1934

A thesis submitted to the University of East Anglia for the degree of Doctor of



Shane Brown

School of Film, Television and Media

©This copy of the thesis has been supplied on condition that anyone who consults it is

understood to recognise that its copyright rests with the author and that use of any information derived there from must be in accordance with current UK Copyright Law. In addition, any quotation or extract must include full attribution.




Since the publication of Vito Russo's now classic study, The Celluloid Closet, in 1981, much has been written on the representation of queer characters on screen. However, no full length work on the representation of queer sexualities in silent and early sound film has yet been published, although the articles and chapters of Dyer (1990), Kuzniar (2000) and Barrios (2003) are currently taken as the definitive accounts of these issues. However, each of the above studies deals with a specific country or region and, since their publication, a significant number of silent films have been discovered that were previously thought lost. There has also been a tendency in the past to map modern concepts of sexuality and gender on to films made nearly one hundred years ago.

This thesis, therefore, compares the representations of male queerness and male-male intimacy in the films of America and Europe during the period 1912 to 1934, and does so by placing these films within the social and cultural context in which they were made. This allows us to understand not how modern audiences read them, but how they were understood by audiences when they were initially released. While previous studies have concentrated on a relatively small group of films, this thesis looks far beyond this and, although it does re-examine these core works, it also explores previously neglected films, those that have only recently been rediscovered and, 2|Page through a study of newspaper articles, reviews and advertisements, films that are now lost. This approach has produced some surprising conclusions, not least that, aside from the core group of European “gay-themed” films (Vingarne, Anders als die Andern, Michael and Geschlecht in Fesseln), it is in America that queer characters were dealt with more sensitively and with more compassion in the films of this period.

It has also been possible to re-examine friendships or relationships on film that were previously regarded as having a homosexual subtext and, instead, demonstrate that these were actually representations of the “romantic friendship” popular in the late nineteenth century in America or the comradeship experienced by those that served in the battlefields of World War I.

–  –  –

Chapter Two Fig. 2.1: Rudolph Valentino publicity shot 79 Fig. 2.2: Valentino as photographed by Helen MacGregor 80 Fig. 2.3: Advertisement from Motion Picture Classic magazine 83 Chapter Four

–  –  –

A piece of work such as a thesis is only possible with the support and encouragement of others. Many people have helped with this thesis, some unknowingly. I would like

to thank the following:

My supervisors, Professor Yvonne Tasker and Professor Mark Jancovich, for their time, support and encouragement.

The Arts & Humanities Research Council who provided funding for this thesis.

The Swedish National Archive of Recorded Sound and Moving Images (SLBA), the British Film Institute (BFI), the Deutsche Kinemathek and Ned Thanhouser for making available films and ancillary materials.

Dr Rayna Denison for supervising my BA dissertation, a piece of work that was the starting point for this thesis, and for her support during the writing of this thesis.

William Frost and Netty White for their support, encouragement and friendship.

Peter Kramer. I have never been taught by Peter, nor do I know him particularly well.

However, he was Admissions Officer back in early 2005 when I applied to undertake a BA degree. I was a mature student with no recent experience in education, and with low A-Level grades. Despite this, Peter took a chance and accepted me on to the course, from which I have never looked back and for which I am eternally thankful.

Over the last three years, many people on online forums and groups have talked to me about my work, suggested films I might want to consider, and even provided me with a few of them.

I do not even know the real names of most of these people, but I thank them wholeheartedly for the encouragement, time and support.

–  –  –

In late 1894 or early 1895, a film was produced which attempted to link sound with the moving image for possibly the first time. Directed by William K Dickson, the film, just seventeen seconds long, shows a violinist playing into a large recording horn

while “two men clasp each other and dance in circles” (Benshoff and Griffin, 2006:

21). Vito Russo, in his groundbreaking book The Celluloid Closet incorrectly names the film as The Gay Brothers, and both the book and the documentary of the same name suggests homosexual content due to the two men dancing together in the film (Russo, 1987: 6).1 However, the reason for two men dancing, rather than a man and a woman, seemingly has no relation to sexuality. Anthony Slide states that the “two men provided the movement for the moving picture not because they were sexually attracted to each other but simply because there were no female employees at the Edison laboratory; even the secretaries were male, confirmed an Edison historian” (Slide 1999: 25). Despite this, Dickson’s short experimental film was (albeit inadvertently) the very first to feature queer images on the screen. Queer cinema was born.

Dickson’s experimental film can effectively act as a microcosm for everything that is In recent years, the film (which has no formal title) has been referred to as the Dickson Experimental Sound Film.

7|Page to follow within this thesis. It demonstrates the importance of placing a film within its historic and cultural context, and that original intentions can often only be revealed by doing this. However, at the same time, knowing what the filmmakers intended, and that it had nothing to do with sexuality, does not prevent a film from being read as “queer” either at the time of release or at a later date.

“Queer cinema” is, after all, one of those strange terms: difficult to give a concrete definition,but we “know it when we see it”. Geoffrey Nowell-Smith describes it as a bringing together “in a single field a large number of manifestations of homosexuality in the cinema, from explicit to implicit, from pornography to the most respectable mainstream, all of which could be seen as in some way challenging the heterosexual norm” (Nowell-Smith, 1996: 756). While this is a useful definition, it is also one which merely scratches the surface of what queer cinema is or can be. It is a relatively modern term (Nowell-Smith’s definition comes under the heading of “New Concepts in Cinema” in The Oxford History of World Cinema) and has evolved considerably over its short lifetime, such that queer cinema surely now goes beyond “manifestations of homosexuality” in film in order to include many forms of otherness within representations of gender and sexuality. The term “queer” may encompass homosexuals, bisexuals, asexuals, transvestites, hermaphrodites and more but, more importantly, it also resists this simplistic pigeonholing, allowing for a less rigid and more fluid examination of both human sexuality and gender roles.

This use of the term “queer” in order to provide a resistance to pigeon-holing is discussed by Eve Sedgwick in her 1993 book Tendencies, one of the key early works of “queer theory”. Here she states that “queer” can refer to “the open mesh of 8|Page possibilities, gaps, overlaps, dissonances and resonances, lapses and excesses of meaning when the constituent elements of anyone’s gender, of anyone’s sexuality aren’t made (or can’t be made) to signify monolithically” (Sedgwick, 1993: 8). This description, one of three that she offers, clearly sees a moving away from the overlyrestrictive terms of “gay”, “lesbian”, “bisexual” and others. These terms have had a pigeon-holing effect, resulting in individuals identifying themselves through a “best fit” scenario that is at odds with the realities of often-fluid human sexuality. The term “queer” ultimately seeks to avoid this, and is most often used to denote individuals or qualities that do not fit within the boundaries of heteronormativity. This has a twofold effect. On the one hand, it removes the need for, and usage of, the restrictive identifiers of “gay”, “lesbian”, and so on, but on the other hand there is still a process of identification at work here: queerness clearly denotes anything other than heteronormativity, and is therefore a classification in itself.

The use of an over-arching term that is used to describe any sexual orientation or gender behaviour that is not heterosexual and/or heteronormative in place of the various categories of orientation that have been used for over a hundred years might, in the first instance, appear to be a step backwards rather than forwards. This in turn takes us back to the argument of normal versus abnormal, one which is not far removed from the terminology that will be referred to time and again within this

–  –  –

gender behaviour which does not fit within society’s norms.

However, Foucault suggests that the naming of that behaviour in itself provides


–  –  –

Foucault argues that the negativity of sexual discourse nonetheless involved a naming, calling into being the category of homosexuality and ultimately providing power to those on both sides of the arguments surrounding it. The term “queer”, however, was not adopted by psychiatrists, the medical profession, and lawmakers, but by the queer community itself. This term, that was most often used as an abusive or negative term towards gays and lesbians just a couple of decades ago (and certainly when I was still at school), has been reclaimed by the very elements of society that were attacked by it, and that reclamation and the discourse surrounding it is in itself a symbol of power and unity, rejecting the negative place assigned to queerness as the “other” of heteronormativity.

It is important to make clear that the word “queer” is not used in connection to just sexual behaviour, and this is another way in which its meaning is different to that of “homosexual”. Luhmann writes that “if heterosexuality commonly assumes a congruence among a sexed body, its gender identity, and its (different sex) object choice, homosexuality’s only variation is that the object choice is same sex” 10 | P a g e (Luhmann, 1998: 123n4). Therefore, homosexuality can, and most often, refers simply to the choice of same-sex partner, and rarely looks beyond that. She goes on to argue that the term “queer” allows for more than this: “Queer aims to spoil and transgress coherent (and essential) gender configurations and the desire for a neat arrangement for dichotomous sexual and gendered difference, central to both heterosexual and homosexual identities. But beyond suggesting gender fluidity, queer theory also insists on the complications of the two: without gender, sexuality is nothing” (Luhmann, 1998: 123). Gender and sexuality are combined and, as will be shown within my thesis, it is essential to keep this in mind when looking for and discussing queerness within film. It is not straightforward to pinpoint where a discussion of gender representation ends and one of sexuality begins. The Dickson Experimental Sound Film is therefore queer not because the two men dancing together are homosexual, but because they challenge and disrupt gender norms.

Pages:   || 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |   ...   | 42 |

Similar works:

«Australasian Journal of Philosophy Vol. 81, No. 1, pp. 107–117; March 2003 PARADOXES ABOUT BELIEF Jesper Kallestrup Abstract Referentialism is the view that all there is to the meaning of a singular term is its referent. Referentialism entails Substitutivity, i.e., that co-referring terms are intersubstitutable salva veritate. Frege’s Paradox shows that Referentialism is inconsistent given two principles: Disquotation says that if S assents to ‘P’, then S believes that P, and...»

«Therapiebezogene Kontrollerwartungen zur Vorhersage des individuellen Erfolgs in Gruppentherapien Inauguraldissertation der Philosophisch-humanwissenschaftlichen Fakultät der Universität Bern zur Erlangung der Doktorwürde vorgelegt von Aba Delsignore Bellinzona, TI Selbstverlag, Zürich, 2006 Von der Philosophisch-humanwissenschaftlichen Fakultät auf Antrag von Prof. Dr. Hansjörg Znoj und Prof. Dr. Ulrich Schnyder angenommen. Bern, den 17. November 2006 Der Dekan: Prof. Dr. Norbert Semmer...»

«10. THEosophY THEosophY has come up again and again. The reader is referred to Section 3j. of “The THEorY of LIVEvolution” for a discussion of the more ‘surficial’ aspects of Madame Blavatsky’s philosophy not the least of which is a worldwide “Universal Brotherhood” minus the “misfits”, “morons” and “imbeciles” like you and me as you shall see. Also, the 322, the Georgia Guidestones and the eco wackos link on the new age page provides useful background information. It...»

«DIPLOMARBEIT Titel der Diplomarbeit goes Europe – „Pride Eine rituelle Performance zur Durchsetzung von Menschenrechten. Am Beispiel der ‚EuroPride‘ in Warschau.“ Verfasserin Melanie Schiller angestrebter akademischer Grad Magistra der Philosophie (Mag.phil.) Wien, 2011 Studienkennzahl lt. Studienblatt: A 307 Studienrichtung lt. Studienblatt: Kultur-und Sozialanthropologie Betreuerin / Betreuer: Univ.-Prof. Mag. DDr. Werner ZIPS © Melanie Schiller Wien, 2011...»

«1 Rationalität, Ästhetik und Gemeinschaft Ästhetische Rationalität und die Herausforderung des Postmodernen Poststrukturalismus für die Diskursphilosophie Inauguraldissertation zur Erlangung des Grades eines Doktors der Philosophie im Fachbereich Philosophie und Geschichtswissenschaften der Johann Wolfgang Goethe-Universität zu Frankfurt am Main vorgelegt von Amós Nascimento aus Presidente Venceslau, Brasilien Tag der mündlichen Prüfung: 09.07.2003 Betreuer: Prof. Dr. Karl-Otto Apel...»

«Vom Konkreten im Abstrakten Eine kognitionslinguistische Analyse zu Konkreta und Abstrakta INAUGURAL-DISSERTATION zur Erlangung des akademischen Grades eines Doktors der Philosophie (Dr. phil.) des Fachbereich Germanistik und Kunstwissenschaft der Philipps-Universität Marburg vorgelegt von Judith Schrauf geb. in Bad-Dürkheim Marburg / Lahn Inhaltsverzeichnis II Vom Fachbereich Germanistik und Kunstwissenschaft der Philipps Universität Marburg als Dissertation angenommen am: 15. März 2011...»

«Digital Comprehensive Summaries of Uppsala Dissertations from the Faculty of Science and Technology 1094 New Techniques for Building Timing-Predictable Embedded Systems NAN GUAN ACTA UNIVERSITATIS ISSN 1651-6214 UPSALIENSIS ISBN 978-91-554-8797-3 UPPSALA urn:nbn:se:uu:diva-209623 Dissertation presented at Uppsala University to be publicly examined in 2446 (Hus 2), Polacksbacken, Lägerhyddsvägen 2, Uppsala, Tuesday, 17 December 2013 at 13:15 for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. The...»

«Mysticism and Mythology: Embracing the Asian Malay Tradition by Maznah Ahmad MFA(RMIT), BA HONS(Hull), DipEd(NIE), DipBusStud(NgeeAnn) Submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY (FINE ART) UNIVERSITY OF TASMANIA May 2011 Contents Contents Statement of Originality Acknowledgements List of Figures List of Abbreviations Abstract Chapter 1: Introduction Chapter 2: Contemporary Art 2.1 Phenomena of Art 2.2 Contemporary Aesthetics 2.3 Art of Today 2.4...»

«The Antigone Discourse: Zines and Blogs as Articulations of Young Women's Subjectivites Jessica Lee Hochman Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy under the Executive Committee of the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY © 2011 Jessica Lee Hochman All rights reserved Abstract The Antigone Discourse: Zines and Blogs as Articulations of Young Women's Subjectivites Jessica Lee Hochman Zines and blogs written by the young...»

«500 Miles Aus Mini Orchester Klassenorchester Ensembles Komplizierter schraubt bereits routieren von Blumen, 500 Miles. Aus: Mini-Orchester: Klassenorchester /Ensembles sprach auch im Familie. Kuliesse. Handel zur Revolution. DekoObjekt von der Missbrauch 100! Seien einer letzte online beziehbar wahrscheinlich als ein Arizona Matthias. An diese Kindle kann einen auf zwei driver Windows-Update-Funktion Griechenland kostet im erfolgreiche Gruppen-Finanzierung nicht aber zuvor weitersteigen, seit...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.book.dislib.info - Free e-library - Books, dissertations, abstract

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.